tblt.gif

Tang Ben Forum

Chinese Software

美國.洛杉磯

tangben@tangben.com

 

 

美國失去一位東亞問題學者

THE DEATH OF AN AMERICAN SCHOLAR OF EAST ASIA

TOM PLATE

 Scholars and journalists don’t always get along (right, call this Dept. of Understatement).  But their need for each other is endless and often deep, even when each side bull-headedly refuses to admit it.

Let’s put the matter this way:

Journalists are generally scavenger birds of the moment, tweeting their view of contemporary history breathlessly and sometimes (alas) carelessly.

By contrast the true academic is the whale of the knowledge kingdom, diving deep and displacing much when on the hunt for knowledge. I am brazen enough to say that I may actually know what I am talking about: over the decades I have been both an American journalist and an American professor, often at the same time – as, for example, now.

I admit my view of great scholars can trend toward the bucolic and completely ignore the large raft of professorial deadheads, footnote trawlers and tenured mediocrities that populate many universities. In part this positive blindness is because I pointedly avoid the loathsome academic bureaucrats who make you want to tear your hair out and instead invest my time with the greats who inspire you to do better and think more grandly.

This brings me to one professor who by universal acclaim belonged in this special latter category. That was Robert A. Scalapino.  Indeed, now that he is no longer with us – he died at 92 last week – I can tell you what I really thought of him. I thought he was exceptional.

Professor Scalapino worked out of the thrilling fields of the University of California at Berkeley. That alone should tell you something. Okay, so not every professor there is terrific and maybe it’s not inarguably the case that it deserves to be called the greatest American university, as I believe it may well be (I know… there’s Harvard, and my alma mater Princeton … and Stanford…and so on).  But at the very least it’s a very special world with special people. And, until Nov. 1, Scalapino was one of them.

His expertise as a scholar of Japan politics was widely acclaimed and even attracted the attention of a handful of advice-hungry U.S. presidents who had found his views helpful indeed. His energies were those of legend – and produced some 40 books and more than 500 scholarly or policy articles. And his reputation for scholarly quality was of the highest order.  Most importantly of all, Scalapino cared deeply about Asia – and about helping Americans understand it well enough to be able to relate to it intelligently.

Scalapino’s radar went beyond Japan, of course. All of East Asia came within his ken. He had so much to say about the Korean Peninsula. And long before America recognized that China was rising and had all but shed Communist economics, Bob was running up the frequent-flier mileage to Beijing. His balanced views of what was happening on the mainland often stood in embarrassing contrast to either the blind Cold War hawks who could see only evil or blindfolded romantic leftists who couldn’t see any.

Alas, I did not know Bob nearly as well as I would have liked. But I shared the dais from time to time, and invaded some of his privileged professorial circles in my prior 15-year run at a sister institution – the University of California in Los Angeles --- so as to catch a glimpse of him.

He had special stature because he was an inspirational figure. Instead of filling an audience with fatigue (personally, I never once saw him use narcolepsy-inducing PowerPoint), he invariably left it wanting more.  Instead of inspiring students to take the safe road, he taught them to reach high.

Mentoring students, at which Scalapino excelled, often comes as a second thought in academic circles and is rarely a formal part of the professorial evaluation procedure at major research universities. But if you think of Socrates and his student Plato, or of Plato and his greatest student Aristotle, and etcetera, etcetera – you might imagine that mentoring the next generation of great scholars and thinkers could prove a scholar’s greatest possible legacy.

To be sure, it’s silly to believe that only the wise and deserving get to live a long rich life. But that, at the age of 92, was to be Scalapino’s fate, and so I will think it the case in this particular circumstance. I will also insist on my view that about Berkeley a certain reverence of appreciation needs to be paid.  Scalapino’s life of distinction is an obvious data point. May this giant of American academe indeed rest in peace.

 
 

論壇主頁

今日短評

快訊快評

今日幽默

今日妙語

新聞述評

網友論壇

縱論天下

脫口秀

兩個兩岸

獨語天涯

咖啡廳

人生自白

美國筆記

景涵文集

天才兒童

西雅圖夜話

網友漫筆

楓葉傳真

劍橋偶拾

美國札記

千里帷幄

情詩欣賞

燕山夜話

千載清謠

瑞典茉莉

聚焦香港

澳洲思絮

洛城夜話

創業雜誌

法律世界

新科技

網友來函

喜馬拉雅

財經趨勢

自由言論

華府鉤沉

星條旗下

社區服務

日耳曼專稿

銀幕縱深

硅谷清流

 

 

 

對本網站有任何建議或有任何體會要與大家分享,請發往 tangben@tangben.com

一九九九年七月二十二日正式上網
Copyright © 2000, 2001, 2002 TANG BEN